Bay County Disc Golf · Post-event surveys, Nov 2021 – Jul 2026

Locals rate our layouts a point higher than visitors at every event, and our main survey question can't see it

This page pulls together 11 post-event surveys and 845 player responses across every Bay County Disc Golf event series: Monster Mash, NWFL Championship, Kickoff, Tinsel Toss and Maximum Freedom. It covers what players keep telling us once the noise is filtered out, how each event scored, which questions earned their place, and one survey template to use after any event.

Lessons · every BCDG event, 2021–2026

What to keep, what to change, what to stop

Each headline holds up across events after filtering out filler answers, weather complaints, and the boost locals give our layouts. The line under each one names the events behind it.

Keep

It's working

Event operations are the reason people come back

"Well run," "organized," "smooth" and "the people" are the top reasons to return at every event series, from visitors as well as locals. Visitors rate us 8.96–9.50 on refer-a-friend even at our roughest events. Check-in, card spacing, and fixing problems mid-round are the brand.

All 11 surveys · visitors and locals

A pack built around one item people want

Pack scores were weakest when the pack was a bundle of small items (7.58–7.99 across the 2023 Kickoff, 2023 Monster Mash and 2024 NWFL). They jumped when one standout item anchored it: the jersey (favorite for 67–79%) and Max Freedom's disc plus payout. Locals don't inflate pack scores, so this read is trustworthy.

Kickoff, Monster Mash, NWFL, Max Freedom · no local bias

One or two signature holes per event

Showpiece holes are what people name as favorites: the ghost hole (38% perfect 10s), island holes, and the temporary NWFL holes (8.75–8.92). 70% said yes to a 27-hole one-round "Mega Monster."

Monster Mash, NWFL · 2023–2026

A clear identity for each event

The events with a hook score best: Max Freedom's no-OB rules (our top event, overall 9.36 from visitors), Halloween decorations (59% perfect 10s), and the Tinsel Toss's green layout (9.26, with every respondent giving referral a 9 or 10). Each event should have one thing players can name.

Max Freedom, Monster Mash, Tinsel Toss

Lower-friction formats to grow the field

Max Freedom (cheaper entry, real payout, no OB) scored highest with first-timers and visitors alike, and nobody rated it under 7. Use it as the template for events meant to bring in new players.

Max Freedom · 44 responses
Change

Do differently

Set layout difficulty for visitors and lower divisions, not for locals

Locals rated our layouts 0.7–1.1 points higher than visitors at all 5 events we can split. Players who play a few events a year elsewhere are the harshest (29% scored the 2025 Monster Mash layout 6 or lower). Give MA4, MA60, women and juniors shorter tees, and get feedback on new layouts from out-of-town players before the event.

Monster Mash, NWFL, Max Freedom · 5 of 5 events

Plan pace for full fields

Pace complaints rise with field size and layout length: card waits in 2022, "two rounds of 22 holes" in 2024, a 5.5-hour round in 2025, and 6 visitor comments at the 2025 NWFL. Cap cards at 4, keep juniors out of the main waves, and size the layout to the field.

Monster Mash 2022–2025, NWFL 2025 · mostly visitors

Make OB obvious whenever the layout isn't standard

OB, mandos and hazard lines are the top hole complaint at every event with custom or temporary holes: 12 of 38 real hole comments at the 2025 Monster Mash and 15 of 33 at the 2025 NWFL, mostly from visitors. Put OB maps in the caddy book 2 weeks out, flag lines instead of only painting them, and put turf on temporary tees.

Monster Mash, NWFL · 2021, 2024–2026

Get the basics right: cold water, restrooms, food

Water, food and a back-nine restroom come up at nearly every event since 2022, including Max Freedom (cold water, a cold room) and the 2023 Kickoff (bathrooms). These are cheap fixes that carry over to every event. Locals raise them the most because they play the course year-round.

Every series · 2022–2026

Finish faster

Run awards right after play, keep the raffle short ("held hostage for over an hour," 2024), and have trophies ready ("order trophies sooner," 2026 NWFL). The last 30 minutes are what people drive home thinking about.

Monster Mash 2023–2024, NWFL 2026

Make side contests and extras opt-in

Themed extras split the field: 38% rated the 2023 Monster Mash fun extras 6 or lower, while its decorations scored high. Keep contests for the people who want them and off everyone else's clock.

Monster Mash 2023
Stop

Let it go

Using refer-a-friend as our health score

93–95% of locals give it a 9 or 10, so it's flat and inflated. Use overall experience, play again, and the layout rating split by division, and report visitor-only numbers as the headline.

All events

Counting weather as feedback

Wind and rain were 16 of the 38 real "do better" answers at the 2026 NWFL. We can't change them, so tally them separately and leave them out of decisions. The only usable weather signal is event date.

Every event

Required open-text questions

36–52% of answers to the main "do better" question are filler like "nothing," ".", "keep it up" or jokes. Make every text question optional and get structure from checkboxes and grids.

Monster Mash, NWFL, Max Freedom · 2024–2026

Pack filler

"Most of the stuff from the pack is trash" (2022). A mini nobody used, custom discs with no flight numbers (2024), mixed feelings on hats (2026), and "for $65 there should be more." People ask for discs, shirts, towels and hand warmers they'll use. Fewer, better items, or a lower no-pack price.

Monster Mash, Kickoff, NWFL · 2022–2026

Acting on one-off requests

A single comment (bikini contest, valet parking, "10-stroke handicap for MPO") is a story, not a signal. Act when a theme shows up from several people or at more than one event.

Rule of thumb
Filtering the noise

Locals are kinder to our layouts. Visitors are the honest read.

Response-by-response data from five events (2024–2026), split by whether the player lives in Bay County. Each line runs from the visitor average to the local average.

Average score, visitors vs locals

VisitorsLocals (Bay County)

Locals rate the layout higher at every event and refer-a-friend higher by about half a point. The player pack is the exception, where locals score it the same or lower. That makes the pack score the cleanest read we have, and the layout score the one most in need of a visitor-only view.

Layout gap+0.7 to +1.1

How much higher locals rate the layout than visitors, at all 5 events.

Filler answers36–52%

Share of "what can we do better" answers that say nothing, across the five events with response data.

Weather16 of 38

Real complaints at the 2026 NWFL that were about wind or rain.

Toughest critics29%

Players who play a few events a year elsewhere and scored the 2025 layout 6 or lower. These are the players we're trying to win.

Refer-a-friend, all events
81 median

Promoter score ranges 70–91 across 10 events (the 23-response Tinsel Toss hit 100). It's high everywhere, which is why it can't tell events apart.

Local layout boost
+0.7–1.1

How much higher locals rate the layout than visitors, at every event we can split.

Player pack swing
7.58 → 9.02

Pack scores ranged from 7.58 (2023 Monster Mash) to 9.02 (2026 Max Freedom). It's the score we've moved most by changing what we do.

Visitors
48–83%

Share of respondents from outside Bay County at our Monster Mash and NWFL events. Our tournaments draw a regional field.

  1. 01
    Refer-a-friend is the only question we've asked at every event, and it hits a ceiling. At most events 70–85% of players give it a 9 or 10, and locals give it 9–10 more than 90% of the time. It dipped in 2023–24 but couldn't tell us why.
  2. 02
    The questions that changed what we did were specific ones. Pack scores bottomed out at the 2023 Kickoff, 2023 Monster Mash and 2024 NWFL, then climbed once the jersey arrived. Hole-level and new-hole questions at the Monster Mash and NWFL produced the most detailed, usable comments of anything we asked.
  3. 03
    Our biggest problems show up only in free text. Pace of play, layouts too hard for some divisions, and unclear OB on temporary holes have never been asked as a scored question. We also stopped asking division at some events, so we can't tell who's struggling.
  4. 04
    Required free-text questions collect filler. "Most likely reason you'd attend again" has come back "community, well run, it's local" at every event since 2023. 36–52% of "do better" answers say nothing at all.
  5. 05
    Tournaments draw a regional crowd; club events draw members. 48–83% of Monster Mash and NWFL respondents came from outside Bay County. The Tinsel Toss and Max Freedom are half to 70% local. That's evidence for tourism and sponsor asks, and a reason to read tournament and club-event scores differently.
Trend

Refer-a-friend score by event

The one question asked at every event, in date order. Lines connect the two tournament series, and club events are dots. Hover a point for the breakdown.

Promoter score (% 9–10 minus % 0–6)

Monster MashNWFL ChampionshipKickoff / Max Freedom

Early surveys used 0–10 and later ones 1–10, so very old and very new scores aren't a perfect match. The 2025 Tinsel Toss (23 responses, all 9–10) scores 100 and isn't drawn because the sample is small.

Every rating

How each scored question spread out

Each bar splits responses into 0–6 (unhappy), 7–8 (fine) and 9–10 (loved it). The right column shows the average and the share of perfect 10s.

0–67–89–10
Event series

How each series is doing

Five event series have post-event surveys. Tournaments (Monster Mash, NWFL) draw a regional field; club events (Tinsel Toss, Max Freedom) draw more members, so their scores run higher.

Oct/Nov · 2021–2025 · 5 surveys · 495 responses

Monster Mash

  • Promoter score 91 → 85 → 73 → 70 → 80. Our largest field and longest-running survey.
  • 48–67% visitors, and rising.
  • Pack went from 7.58 (2023) to 8.89 once the jersey arrived.
  • Pace of play and custom-layout difficulty are the open problems.
March · 2024–2026 · 3 surveys · 194 responses

NWFL Championship

  • Promoter score steady at 80–81 every year.
  • Our most visitor-heavy event (83% in 2024).
  • New and temporary holes score well (8.75–8.92), but the 2024 hole 14 redesign split the field: 52% at 6 or lower.
  • Pack 7.61 → 8.81 → 8.24. Players missed the jersey in 2026, and weather drove most 2026 complaints.
  • 70% said yes to a 27-hole "Mega Monster" (2025).
January · 2023 · 89 responses

Bay County Kickoff

  • Promoter score 82. Navigation 9.6.
  • Pack 7.99, with 25% at 6 or lower. Hot sauce beat the DyeMax disc as favorite item.
  • Worn tee pads, bathrooms, and requests for doubles and a putting league.
January · 2025 · 23 responses

Tinsel Toss

  • Every respondent gave referral a 9 or 10. Green layout 9.26.
  • 70% local, a club-member crowd. Too small a sample to compare with the tournaments.
July · 2026 · 44 responses

Maximum Freedom

  • Our best scores: promoter 89, overall 9.61, play again 9.61.
  • No-OB, no-mando rules: 73% gave them a 10. Visitors still rated the layout a point below locals.
  • Pack plus payout together was the reason to return for 30 of 44.
  • Asked for cold water, a cold room, and tee times that match PDGA.
Deep dive · Monster Mash, 2021–2025

Our longest-running survey, year by year

The Monster Mash is the only event surveyed five years running, so it shows what changes when we change things. Ratings come from the scored questions. "Loved" and "Didn't love" summarize the free-text answers, and quotes are trimmed.

Koep Corp
2021
Responses
74
Promoter
91
Pack
9.35
Tee pads
8.19
Caddy book
9.64
2-day interest
64% yes

Loved

  • Smooth, fast event with no hiccups
  • New walking planks on the far side
  • Clear caddy book and easy navigation (73–74% gave 10s)

Didn't love

  • Tee pads, the lowest score that year (15% rated them 6 or lower)
  • Hole 6 OB unclear: the caddy book said flags
  • Wind (the running joke every year)

AskedLayout, heard-about, refer club, refer course, travel, caddy book, navigation, tee pads, pack, 2-day tee time interest, 3 open text.

Book That Condo
2022
Responses
104
Promoter
85
Pack
8.41
Caddy book
9.36
Navigation
9.52
2-day interest
62% yes

Loved

  • Card spacing and flow: "very little waiting on tee boxes"
  • Decorations, photographers, food truck on site
  • Fast check-in and quick awards
  • Contests and costumes

Didn't love

  • Player pack (17% scored 6 or lower). "Most of the stuff from the pack is trash"
  • No restroom on the back half
  • Water and shade on course
  • Some long waits between holes, smoking on cards

AskedSame as 2021 minus tee pads, plus zip code. Three open-text questions.

4th Annual
2023
Responses
97
Promoter
73
Pack
7.58
Ghost hole
8.18
Decorations
7.97
Costume/fun
7.12

Loved

  • Ghost hole: 38% gave it a 10, and people asked for more
  • Flow and easy check-in, fewer backups
  • Decorations (59% gave them a 10)

Didn't love

  • Player pack, the worst year: 30% scored it 6 or lower
  • Fun extras split people: 38% rated the costume contest 6 or lower and 11 people gave decorations a 1
  • Awards not run right after play; signs placed where they affected play

AskedLayout, refer club, refer course, decorations, heard-about, travel, pack, ghost hole, fun parts, 5 open text.

5th Annual
2024
Responses
114
Promoter
70
Layout
8.37
Pack
8.89
First event
20%
New to BCDG
31%

Loved

  • The custom jersey: favorite pack item for 79%
  • Island on hole 2, the 270' water carry
  • A fun atmosphere with a "community event" feel

Didn't love

  • Two rounds of 22 holes ran long
  • Raffle kept people over an hour after play
  • Splitting the iconic par 5; the hole 4 change
  • Warm water, limited food; custom discs had no flight numbers

AskedZip, travel, tournament experience, played BCDG before, played Majette before, custom layout, refer, heard-about, pack, favorite item, hole good/bad, 4 open text.

6th Annual
2025
Responses
106
Promoter
80
Overall
8.77
Layout
8.14
Pack
8.51
From outside Bay
67%

Loved

  • The people and the staff: "always a class act"
  • Ghost hole, triple mando, holes 18 and 21
  • Jersey again (67%); the Silipint and disc choices
  • Problems got fixed mid-event: "second round was butter"

Didn't love

  • Pace of play: ~23 comments about a 5.5-hour first round and 4 groups waiting at a tee
  • Layout too hard for ams, women, MA60 and juniors (~7)
  • OB lines tighter than 2024, unclear "rivers", hole 4 island with no drop
  • Food and cold water (~9); porta-potty near 12/16; kids in the main field
"Subtle tweaks to OB lines between '24 and '25 made things play a bit tighter… perhaps a little too tight."

AskedOverall, zip, travel, tournament experience, custom layout, refer, heard-about, pack, favorite item, 6 open text (4 of them required). Division played was not asked.

Who comes

Where players come from and how they heard

Travel and lodging

Lives in Bay CountyDay tripStayed overnight
How players heard about each event
How they heard (% of respondents)Disc Golf SceneFriendClub eventFacebookDiscordInstagram

Discord wasn't a listed option until 2026. Once it was, 17–23% picked it, so earlier years probably undercount it. Facebook's share at the Monster Mash fell from 35% in 2022 to 25% in 2025, while "a friend" rose from 26% to 46%.

Question scorecard

Every question we've asked, and whether it earned its place

QuestionTimes askedWhat it told usVerdict
Refer Bay County events to a friend (0–10)11Our only multi-year trend. Hits a ceiling and can't explain a drop.Keep
Overall event experience4Spreads scores out more than refer-a-friend (48% vs 69% perfect 10s at the 2025 Monster Mash).Keep
Custom layout / new holes rating5Our lowest-scoring recurring question, and the most inflated by locals. Flags trouble but not which division or hole.Keep + split by division
Any holes stand out good or bad?3The most detailed, usable feedback we've collected.Fix: hole picker
Player pack rating + favorite item10Led directly to the jersey. Works best when the item list matches the actual pack.Keep
What can we do better?11Where pace, water, food and restroom problems surfaced.Keep, optional
Concept tests (2-day event, Mega Monster)3Clear answers when a decision was pending: 62–70% yes.Keep, rotate
How did you hear about it?11Shows which channels work. Discord was missing from the list until 2026.Fix options
Travel and lodging11Visitor share for grants and sponsors.Keep
Tournament experience6Useful for segmenting, but answer choices changed between years.Fix: lock wording
Division / layout played7Dropped in 2025, the year we needed it most.Add back
Pace of play / round length02025's top complaint, never scored.Add
Play this event again next year?1More direct than refer-a-friend. Asked only at Max Freedom.Add
Caddy book / OB clarity2Hit a ceiling on the standard layout. Custom and temporary holes made it a complaint again.Add for custom layouts
Decorations, ghost hole, costume contest1Showed the split opinions on extras. Better covered by one element grid.Fold into grid
Refer The Monster at Majette course4Within 0.1 of the club question every time.Drop
Navigation during play3About 75% gave 10s every time. Tells us nothing new.Drop
Zip code (free text)6+Messy entries ("W", "666y6"). Travel covers most of it.Drop or validate
Most likely reason to attend again9Same answer since 2023: community, well run, local.Drop
One thing you'd like BCDG to do9Mostly "more tournaments." Filler when required.Drop or optional
Proposed · every BCDG event

One survey template for every event

About 4 minutes. Every rating question is required and every open-text question is optional. The core questions stay word-for-word the same at every event so scores compare across events and years. Section 3 and the grid rows in section 4 swap to fit each event, and one rotating question tests an idea.

Core every eventEvent tailor per eventRotate test an idea

1 · About your day

~30 sec
1
Which division did you play?
Dropdown of every division on Disc Golf Scene

Lets every other answer be split by division. Without it we can't tell whether "too hard" came from MA4 or MPO.

CoreRequired
2
How would you describe your tournament experience?
This was my first oneI've only played Bay County eventsI play a few a year in different placesI play events regularly

Keep this exact wording from now on so years compare.

Core
3
What did you do for travel and lodging?
I live in Bay CountyDrove over the day ofStayed with a friendStayed in a hotel or rentalCamped / RV

Visitor share for tourism and sponsor asks. Replaces zip code.

Core
4
How did you hear about the event? (choose all that apply)
Disc Golf SceneFacebookInstagramDiscordAt a club event or leagueA friendOther
Core

2 · The big three

~20 sec · all 0–10
5
Overall, how would you rate [event name]?
012345678910

Baselines: 2025 Monster Mash 8.77, 2026 NWFL 8.98, 2026 Max Freedom 9.61.

Core
6
How likely are you to recommend Bay County Disc Golf events to a friend?
012345678910

Keeps the one trend line we have at every event since 2021 (median promoter score 81).

Core
7
How likely are you to play [event name] next year?
012345678910

The most direct measure of whether the day worked for that player.

Core

3 · The layout

~1 min · tailor per event
8
For your division, the layout was…
Too easyA little easyAbout rightA little hardToo hard

Paired with Q1, this shows which divisions the layout is too hard for, not just that it's too hard.

Event
9
Rate this event's layout overall.
012345678910

Compare against the same event last year. Read it split by local vs visitor, since locals score layouts about a point higher.

Event
10
Which holes were your favorites? (pick up to 3)
12345678910111213141516171819202122Ghost

In Google Forms, use checkboxes with "Limit to 3" response validation. Match the hole list to the event's layout, including temporary holes. Checkboxes turn a long essay question into a ranked list we can count.

Event
11
Which holes would you change? (pick up to 3)
Same hole list as Q10
Event
12
What would you change about those holes?
Paragraph · optional

Keeps the detailed hole-by-hole notes that were the best feedback at the Monster Mash and NWFL.

Event
13
How clear were OB lines, hazards and mandos, on the course and in the caddy book?
Always clearMostly clearSometimes confusingOften confusing

Use whenever there are custom or temporary holes. OB is the top hole complaint at those events. Skip it on the standard layout.

Event

4 · The event

~1 min
14
How did these parts of the day go for you?
Loved itIt was fineDidn't love itDidn't notice
Check-in
Pace of play
Water on the course
Food options
Restrooms
Event theme and extras
Special or temporary holes
Raffle and awards timing
Photographers
Info before the event (layout, caddy book)

One Google Forms multiple-choice grid that puts every recurring complaint on one comparable scale. Keep the first five rows at every event and swap the rest to fit (decorations at the Monster Mash, payout at Max Freedom). "Didn't notice" keeps people from guessing.

Event
15
About how long did your longest round take?
Under 3 hours3–4 hours4–5 hoursOver 5 hours

Puts a number on pace, the top complaint at our biggest fields. Combined with Q1, it shows which divisions got stuck.

Event
16
How would you rate the player pack for the entry fee?
012345678910

Comparable with pack ratings at every past event, now tied to price, which players raised at the Kickoff, Monster Mash and NWFL.

Core
17
What was your favorite part of the player pack?
One option per actual pack itemI played pro (no pack)
Core
18
Would you choose a lower entry fee with no player pack?
YesNoMaybe

One rotating question per event to test a pending decision. Past examples: a 2-day tee-time event (62–64% yes) and the 27-hole Mega Monster (70% yes). This one tests a request raised in 2023, 2025 and 2026.

Rotate

5 · In your words

optional
19
What was the best part of your day?
Short answer · optional
Core
20
What's one thing we should fix for next year?
Paragraph · optional
Core
21
Anything else?
Paragraph · optional
Core

Running it

  • Send it within 24 hours, while round times and hole details are fresh. Past surveys got most responses on day one.
  • Keep core questions word-for-word identical at every event. Changed wording is why tournament-experience answers don't compare today.
  • Report every score two ways: all players, and visitors only. Treat the visitor number as the headline for tournaments.
  • Retire zip code, "most likely reason to attend again," and any required open-text question.
  • Tally weather comments separately, and act on a theme only when several players or more than one event raise it.

Copy the question list

Plain text you can paste into a Google Doc or a new form.